With the release of the colloquially called ’Milburn Report’, its author, Rt Hon Alan, has called for businesses to play a greater role in creating jobs, apprenticeships and training opportunities. Online editor Benjamin Austin reports.
Alan Milburn’s conclusion following the publication of his report titled From a Welfare State to a Working State: A New Settlement for the Next Generation was damning.
Since its commissioning in 2025, the former MP and Secretary of State for Health has been looking into the growing problem of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET).
With the results and Milburn’s conclusions being made public on November 17, he described the current scene as: “A fork in the road for our country.
“Go on as we are and see the NEET crisis grow. Or change course and make the difficult changes that can shift the trajectory. This is a moment of choice.”
The review estimated that almost one million young people aged 16 to 24 are currently NEET, equivalent to approximately one in eight of that age group.
But it is a problem that could not be solved by changing the benefits system alone. Instead, Milburn laid out several suggestions across a 10-year plan, hoping to reduce the number of young people who are NEET to around 5% by 2036.
The current landscape
According to the report, payrolled youth employment rates fell by 4.3% points between December 2022 and December 2025, equivalent to approximately 330,000 young people.
This highlights the need for a different approach, with businesses encouraged to take a more active role in providing first-job opportunities.

Michael Ainsworth
Looking for a reaction from the industry, Michael Ainsworth, managing director and founder of printwear company Involution, said: “I think Alan Milburn has finally highlighted an important issue that successive governments have perhaps pushed down the road for too long.
“Many businesses talk about skills shortages, but at a more fundamental level, too many young people looking for their first meaningful job simply aren’t prepared for the realities of the working environment.
“Society needs to do more to prepare young people for working life, but equally, it must make commercial sense for employers to invest their time and resources in developing productive employees.”
Involution has had many success stories through its apprenticeship schemes and is currently hosting four T Level students from Leeds City College on industry placements, giving them real experience of a working environment while they’re still studying.
Help from business
Milburn believes the UK has placed too much emphasis on academic achievement and university education, while apprenticeships and further education have not received the same attention.
The report suggests making 25,000 initial pre-apprenticeship places and increasing the number of annual apprenticeship starts among under-25s to 270,000 by 2036.
It also calls for technical education to be placed on an equal footing with academic education, with schools, colleges and universities judged partly on how effectively they prepare young people for employment.
Providing young people with opportunities to learn these skills could help businesses address future workforce requirements while making technical careers more attractive to a new generation.
But it will be something that employers would need to be involved in, by providing the opportunity for education and training, and ensuring that the skills being taught reflect the needs of the industries recruiting young people.

Involution has seen much success with apprenticeships
Michael continued: “For me, apprenticeships are a major part of the solution. They provide a structured route into employment, combining practical experience with formal training and qualifications. They also allow employers to develop people with the skills and attitudes their businesses need.
“Few people arrive with all the skills they need. Often, the most important things are attitude, enthusiasm, and a willingness to learn.
“It’s also why I believe apprenticeships are so important. They allow businesses to develop people over time, rather than expecting them to arrive fully trained and ready-made.
“However, we need to recognise that taking on an apprentice is an investment, particularly for smaller businesses. Employers need the right support and incentives to make that commitment worthwhile.”
Government-funded business support
One proposal in the report is to make it to offer financial incentives to businesses to recruit younger workers.
Milburn suggested £3,000 should be paid to employers recruiting someone aged 16 to 24 who has been NEET for at least six months, which could be further supplemented by a £2,000 payment for recruiting someone facing greater barriers to employment, including care leavers and young people with disabilities.
Smaller businesses employing fewer than 50 people would also be eligible for a further £2,000 premium.
The report estimates that this package will help create an additional 170,000 job and apprenticeship opportunities.
It also recommends increasing the existing apprenticeship hiring incentive from £2,000 to £2,500 and extending eligibility to employers that pay the Apprenticeship Levy.
However, the recommendations remain subject to government consideration and implementation, meaning businesses cannot yet assume these payments will be available.
Michael added: “If government genuinely wants employers to take more responsibility for developing young people, it needs to make the financial commitment of employing an apprentice viable and the administrative burden more manageable, particularly for SMEs.
“Ultimately, businesses need good people to survive and grow, and young people need businesses willing to give them an opportunity.
“We shouldn’t expect young people to arrive in the workplace fully formed. Part of our job as employers is to help make them that way.”
The report also calls on employers to reconsider recruitment practices that could prevent inexperienced candidates from securing work.
This includes removing unnecessary previous-experience requirements, using practical assessments and making recruitment criteria clearer.
It also highlights the importance of providing feedback to unsuccessful applicants, arguing that young people should not be left without an explanation following an unsuccessful application.
The hardship for businesses
Businesses have faced increasing employment costs in recent years, such as the increased mandatory National Insurance minimum contribution as well as the increased National Minimum Wage. This has potentially made them more cautious about recruitment.
Rather than proposing an immediate reduction in employer National Insurance across the board, Milburn laid out a five-year plan to reduce National Insurance costs for workers aged 21 to 24, initially targeting retail and hospitality.
The report also calls for the introduction of a Youth Employment Cost Index, published every two years, to assess how government decisions on taxation, wages and employment regulation affect businesses’ ability to recruit younger workers.
A proposed statutory Youth Opportunity Test would also require government to consider the potential impact of major policy decisions on youth employment.
It is obvious that reducing business costs will give them more scope for investment in staff, but could it be an idea that has applications in reality?
What happens next?
For industry, the report presents both an opportunity and a challenge. Businesses are being asked to do more to help young people enter the workforce, but the government is also being urged to make recruitment easier, cheaper and less complicated.
Michael concluded: “We’ve become too focused on academic qualifications as the principal measure of potential and success.
“Being prepared for the realities of working life is equally important. Communication, work ethic, problem-solving, reliability, initiative, and the ability to adapt are just as valuable as academic qualifications in many careers.
“I would particularly like to see apprenticeships given greater recognition and promoted as a first-choice career route, rather than an alternative for those who don’t go to university.
“There is a significant opportunity for businesses to help bridge the gap between education and employment. Apprenticeships allow young people to learn while earning, gain confidence and understand what is expected of them in the workplace.
“But we also need to be realistic. Employers need to see a return on the time and money they invest in training. If we want more businesses, particularly SMEs, to take on apprentices, the funding, support, and administration need to make it an attractive and practical proposition.”
The success of the proposals will ultimately depend on whether businesses are willing to create those opportunities and whether the government delivers the financial and practical support needed to make them viable.
As Milburn makes clear, preparing young people for work is only half the challenge. There must also be employers willing to give them their first opportunity.